Logo Assembly Logo Hemicycle

Keeping political and criminal responsibility separate

Motion for a resolution | Doc. 12749 | 04 October 2011

several Assembly members
Mr Pieter OMTZIGT, Netherlands, EPP/CD ; Mr Pedro AGRAMUNT, Spain, EPP/CD ; Mr Miloš ALIGRUDIĆ, Serbia, EPP/CD ; Ms Marieluise BECK, Germany, ALDE ; Mr Mikael CEDERBRATT, Sweden, EPP/CD ; Mr Georges COLOMBIER, France, EPP/CD ; Mr Ahmet Berat ÇONKAR, Turkey, EDG ; Mr Joseph DEBONO GRECH, Malta, SOC ; Mr József ÉKES, Hungary, EPP/CD ; Mr Joseph FENECH ADAMI, Malta, EPP/CD ; Ms Jana FISCHEROVÁ, Czech Republic, EDG ; Ms Pernille FRAHM, Denmark, UEL ; Mr György FRUNDA, Romania, EPP/CD ; Mr Jean-Charles GARDETTO, Monaco, EPP/CD ; Mr Valeriu GHILETCHI, Republic of Moldova, EPP/CD ; Ms Sylvi GRAHAM, Norway, EPP/CD ; Ms Olha HERASYM'YUK, Ukraine, EPP/CD ; Mr Andres HERKEL, Estonia, EPP/CD ; Mr Kastriot ISLAMI, Albania, SOC ; Mr Željko IVANJI, Serbia, EPP/CD ; Mr Tomáš JIRSA, Czech Republic, EDG ; Mr Ferenc KALMÁR, Hungary, EPP/CD ; Mr Burhan KAYATÜRK, Turkey, EPP/CD ; Mr Haluk KOÇ, Turkey, SOC ; Mr László KOSZORÚS, Hungary, EPP/CD ; Mr Pavol KUBOVIČ, Slovak Republic, EPP/CD ; Ms Kerstin LUNDGREN, Sweden, ALDE ; Ms Nicole MANZONE-SAQUET, Monaco, EPP/CD ; Ms Christine MARIN, France, EPP/CD ; Mr Jean-Claude MIGNON, France, EPP/CD ; Mr Grigore PETRENCO, Republic of Moldova, UEL ; Ms Marietta de POURBAIX-LUNDIN, Sweden, EPP/CD ; Mr Christos POURGOURIDES, Cyprus, EPP/CD ; Mr John PRESCOTT, United Kingdom, SOC ; Ms Mailis REPS, Estonia, ALDE ; Mr François ROCHEBLOINE, France, EPP/CD ; Ms Tatiana ROSOVÁ, Slovak Republic, EPP/CD ; Mr Ilir RUSMALI, Albania, EPP/CD ; Mr Indrek SAAR, Estonia, SOC ; Mr Kimmo SASI, Finland, EPP/CD ; Ms Maria STAVROSITU, Romania, EPP/CD ; Mr Egidijus VAREIKIS, Lithuania, EPP/CD ; Mr Imre VEJKEY, Hungary, EPP/CD ; Mr Luca VOLONTÈ, Italy, EPP/CD ; Mr Johann WADEPHUL, Germany, EPP/CD ; Mr Emanuelis ZINGERIS, Lithuania, EPP/CD

The Assembly finds it necessary to distinguish between political and criminal responsibility. Political decisions shall be judged by parliament and ultimately the voters at the next elections. Criminal acts shall give rise to prosecution, no matter by whom they are committed. Provisions in criminal law effectively criminalising political decision making blur the line between political and criminal responsibility and are open to abuse.

In Ukraine, criminal charges have been filed against a former Prime Minister and several members of her government for “abusing authority or office” and “exceeding authority or official powers” during their term in office. In Iceland, a former Prime Minister is being tried for failing to take appropriate ministerial action during the 2008 banking crisis. In addition, in a number of countries hit by the current debt crisis, calls have been heard to criminally prosecute those seen as politically responsible for it.

In addition to the issue of the possible selective prosecutions, in particular in the Ukrainian example, such cases could amount to the effective criminalisation of political decisions.

Criminalising political decision-making as such violates the rule of law and democratic principles to which all Council of Europe member states are committed to. At the same time, there must be no impunity of political actors who commit or participate in such ordinary crimes as murder, abduction, embezzlement, theft and corruption. As regards crimes specifically concerning the political sphere (such as the prohibition of preparing a war of aggression), these must be narrowly defined and require clear evidence of criminal intent.

Holding governments and their members to account politically is the prerogative of parliaments and ultimately of the electorate. Criminal responsibility must be established by impartial and independent courts, on the basis of prior, clear and narrowly-construed provisions of criminal law. In the light of the above development the Assembly considers that clear European standards need to be developed on the delimitation of criminal and political responsibility.