Family reunification of refugees and migrants in the Council of Europe member States

Doc. 14626: compendium of written amendments | Doc. 14626 | 11/10/2018 | Final version

Contents

A Draft Resolution

B Draft Recommendation

Compendium index

Amendment 2 Amendment 3 Amendment 4 Amendment 1

Caption: AdoptedRejectedWithdrawnNo electronic votes

ADraft Resolution

1The Parliamentary Assembly is deeply concerned about growing political discourse and action against foreigners, which are a real threat to the protection of refugees and in particular their family life. Families must not be torn apart and should not be prevented from reuniting after an often dangerous and challenging departure from their country of origin, where their fundamental rights to safety and security were threatened.

2Recalling that member States are committed to protecting the right to family life under Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ETS No. 5, «the Convention»), the Assembly emphasises that this right applies to everyone, including refugees and migrants. Member States must provide for safe and regular means of family reunification, thus reducing the recourse to smugglers and mitigating the risks associated with irregular migration.

3The Assembly points out that there is no common definition of family with respect to the right to family reunification. While member States may enjoy a broad margin of appreciation in matters concerning morals and religion, family rights require a higher level of protection under the Convention. National authorities should therefore adopt an enabling approach to family reunification beyond the traditional definition of family which does not necessarily correspond to the multitude of ways in which people live together as a family today.

4Children must not be discriminated against because their parents are unmarried, divorced or remarried, because they live in “rainbow” families or because they have been adopted by another person or brought up by grandparents or siblings. National authorities should pay particular attention to vulnerable persons, such as young children and family members with special physical or mental needs, who depend to a larger degree on family reunification. Refugees must also be allowed to demonstrate family links formed in exile or while fleeing.

5People fleeing persecution or war have the right to international protection, and their separated family members have the right to the same protection in accordance with the United Nations Convention relating to the Status of Refugees. States should therefore ensure consistency in granting refugee status to members of the same family and thereby ensure that family life is protected, as required under Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights. Beneficiaries of international protection should have access to information about family reunification procedures, application forms and legal assistance in a language they can understand.

• Amendment 2

10 October 2018

Tabled by Ms Rósa Björk BRYNJÓLFSDÓTTIR, Ms Tineke STRIK, Mr Vernon COAKER, Mr Paul GAVAN, Mr Duarte MARQUES, Mr Domagoj HAJDUKOVIĆ

Votes: 35 in favor 1 against 3 abstentions

In the draft resolution, at the end of paragraph 5, insert the following sentence: "Member States should consider establishing a revolving fund through bilateral agreements or national or European schemes, in order to cover the family reunification costs of beneficiaries of international protection who cannot afford it."

6The Assembly notes with concern that national law often refuses the delivery of visas to family members of individuals who have not been granted refugee status but have been given subsidiary or temporary protection on humanitarian grounds. The protection of family life and the requirements of the best interest of the child under Article 10 of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child necessitate, however, that such persons should be able to maintain their family unity or to reunite with family members. Such subsidiary or temporary protection status must not be considered as an “alternative refugee status” with fewer rights. States should thus not substitute subsidiary or temporary protection status for refugee status, in order to limit family reunification due to the temporary and personal nature of this subsidiary status.

7Regarding migrants, the Assembly emphasises that the protection of their family life and the best interest of the child require that visa requirements for family members of migrants must not be a de facto obstacle to maintaining family unity. The Assembly particularly regrets that some States have high financial requirements or long waiting periods for migrants who wish to apply for visas for their family members. Where States are member of the European Union, European Union legislation on the freedom of movement of persons, including family members, must also be respected.

8Under Article 10.2 of the Convention on the Rights of the Child, a child whose parents reside in different States shall have the right to maintain, on a regular basis, personal relations and direct contacts with both parents. The Assembly regrets that this right is often disregarded in the case of refugees and migrants. National authorities must duly protect this right by ensuring that both parents of a child are identified and contacted and enjoy equal rights to family reunification with their children. No parent must be discriminated against and discriminatory foreign laws must not be implemented by member States if such laws grant more rights to one parent, for instance on gender or religious grounds.

9Regarding minors who apply for refugee status abroad, the Assembly calls on national authorities to respect the Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction, because abduction can also refer to trafficked or smuggled minors or minors accompanied by only one parent. As this convention applies to children up to the age of 16, national authorities should have a distinct procedure for refugees and migrants below this age. This convention must also be respected where unaccompanied children are put under the guardianship of other persons, in order to ensure the protection of family life of those children.

• Amendment 3

10 October 2018

Tabled by Ms Rósa Björk BRYNJÓLFSDÓTTIR, Ms Tineke STRIK, Mr Zafer SIRAKAYA, Lord Simon RUSSELL, Mr Paul GAVAN, Mr Duarte MARQUES, Mr Domagoj HAJDUKOVIĆ

Votes: 36 in favor 2 against 1 abstention

In the draft resolution, at the end of paragraph 9, insert the following sentence: "Ongoing divorce proceedings should not be a hindrance to family reunification, as family reunification must serve primarily the best interests of the child."

10The Assembly recalls that child refugees and minors have rights under the revised European Social Charter (ETS No. 163), including the right to financial and other support by the authorities of the States in which they reside. Therefore, family reunification should not be dependent on the financial situation of a parent who is a migrant or refugee. In this context, the Assembly notes with concern that children are sometimes left behind in another country for financial reasons and the fact that child allowances are often paid irrespective of the actual residence of children under European Union legislation and national laws. In accordance with the European Social Carter, responsibility rests with the national authorities where a child resides.

11The Assembly also underlines that migrant and refugee children belong to the most vulnerable groups, especially those who are unaccompanied and separated from their families. They frequently suffer persistent violations of their human rights and fall through loopholes in child protection frameworks. One of the vital measures is that an effective guardian is appointed.

12Family reunification is often hindered by the fact that the whereabouts of family members are unknown. National authorities must therefore ensure that all refugees and migrants are registered upon arrival and that such data is shared with competent authorities in other member States, in particular through the European Union’s Schengen Visa Information System. This is particularly crucial for unaccompanied minors for tracing and finding their parents and other family members. Without such data, family reunification might become a matter of chance, which is in violation of the right to protection of family life. In this context, the Assembly welcomes the long-standing work of the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) in tracing missing family members and encourages greater co-operation between the ICRC and national authorities.

13Family reunification also requires adequate and functioning administrative procedures by competent authorities, including consular services abroad. Countries of origin must deliver or reissue identification documents without delay and receiving countries must issue refugee status documents or migrant visas, which allow the bearer to travel to family members and maintain family unity also across borders, in accordance with the European Agreement on the Abolition of Visas for Refugees (ETS No. 31) and, where applicable, European Union legislation.

• Amendment 4
• Amendment 1

10 October 2018

Tabled by Ms Rósa Björk BRYNJÓLFSDÓTTIR, Ms Tineke STRIK, Ms Ulla SANDBÆK, Mr Duarte MARQUES, Mr Domagoj HAJDUKOVIĆ, Mr Georgios PSYCHOGIOS

In the draft resolution, paragraph 13, second sentence, replace the words "refugee status documents" with the words "Refugee Convention Travel Documents".

10 October 2018

Tabled by Ms Rósa Björk BRYNJÓLFSDÓTTIR, Ms Tineke STRIK, Mr Zafer SIRAKAYA, Mr Duarte MARQUES, Mr Domagoj HAJDUKOVIĆ

In the draft resolution, at the end of paragraph 13, insert the following sentence: "Member States should accept ICRC travel documents for family reunification purposes."

14The Assembly calls on all member States to develop and respect common guidelines for the implementation of the right to family reunification, in order to ensure that refugees and migrants are not forced to go to those countries where family reunification is easier. Hindrances to the protection of family life are not admissible under Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights to deter migrants or refugees and their family members.

BDraft Recommendation

1Referring to its Resolution … (2018), the Parliamentary Assembly emphasises the importance of protecting family life under Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ETS No. 5) and recommends that the Committee of Ministers:

1.1develop guidelines for the application of the right to family reunification of refugees and migrants as well as for mutual legal assistance and administrative co-operation between member States and with third countries in this field;

1.2invite member States to establish bilateral arrangements to represent each other for the purposes of collecting visa applications and issuing visas;

1.3invite the member States that have not yet done so to join, or co-operate with, the European Union Schengen Visa Information System with a view to exchanging the data necessary for enabling more rapid family reunification;

1.4co-operate with the International Committee of the Red Cross in promoting mechanisms and action for finding missing family members of refugees, in co-operation with national Red Cross and Red Crescent societies and national parliaments;

1.5reinforce Council of Europe action on combating trafficking of child refugees, ensuring that unaccompanied child refugees are reunited with their parents, unless this is against the best interests of a child, for example if parents have participated in the trafficking of this child.