Logo Assembly Logo Hemicycle

PACE President Petra Bayr after prison visits in Türkiye: ‘Court judgments are not suggestions, they are obligations’

PACE President Petra Bayr after prison visits in Türkiye ‘Court judgments are not suggestions, they are obligations’

Petra Bayr, the President of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE), following visits to a number of people in detention in Türkiye, made the following statement:

“I thank the Turkish authorities, and in particular the Turkish delegation to PACE and its Chairperson Yıldırım Tuğrul Türkeş, for making these visits possible. Being able to see people in detention is not a given. It is a sign of dialogue, which I value and intend to further pursue.

This weekend I met Osman Kavala, Selahattin Demirtaş, Figen Yüksekdağ Şenoğlu, Ekrem İmamoğlu and Müzeyyen Doğan.* Most of them have been deprived of their liberty for far too long.

Four of these five cases are before the European Court of Human Rights. In three, the Court has ruled and ordered release. In the fourth, a priority application is pending. Türkiye, like every Council of Europe member state, is bound to implement the Court's judgments. Court judgements are not suggestions. They are obligations. Obligations that have been taken on by all of us. A judgment that is not implemented weakens all of us. A judgment that is implemented strengthens all of us.

One thing is clearer to me after these meetings than ever before. We need the member states of the Council of Europe to speak with one voice, in Strasbourg in the Committee of Ministers and in every bilateral meeting, to insist that the Court's judgments are implemented. At every opportunity, without exception.

I trust that this visit will help us continue a constructive dialogue with the Turkish authorities and pave the way for the full and coherent implementation of the Court’s judgments.

This is not simply about fulfilling legal obligations. It is about strengthening the trust of the Turkish people in their institutions and demonstrating that Türkiye remains genuinely committed to building a truly democratic and pluralistic society, a commitment made more than a century ago, when the modern Turkish Republic was founded. Also the peace process with the Kurdish people will only be successful if it is grounded in the rule of law, democracy and human rights.”

----

* Müzeyyen Doğan is a member of HEVİ LGBTI+ Association, a civil society organisation advocating for LGBTI+ rights and sexual and reproductive rights, arrested in connection with nationwide operations targeting LGBTI+ organisations and activists on 12 September 2026.

PACE President Petra Bayr after prison visits in Türkiye ‘Court judgments are not suggestions, they are obligations’