Reconsideration on substantive grounds of the previously ratified credentials of the Russian delegation
- Parliamentary Assembly
debate on 10 April 2014 (16th Sitting) (see Doc. 13483, report of the Committee on the Honouring of Obligations
and Commitments by Member States of the Council of Europe (Monitoring
Committee), rapporteur: Mr Stefan Schennach; and Doc. 13488, opinion of the Committee on Rules of Procedure, Immunities
and Institutional Affairs, rapporteur: Mr Hans Franken). Text adopted by the Assembly on
10 April 2014 (16th Sitting).
On 21 March 2014, two motions for
a resolution with regard to the previously ratified credentials
of the Russian Federation were submitted to the Parliamentary Assembly.
The first one, signed by 74 members, called for the reconsideration,
on the basis of Rule 9.1.a
the Rules of Procedure of the Assembly, of the ratified credentials
of the Russian delegation on substantive grounds (Doc. 13457
credentials of the Russian delegation). Condemning “without reservation
the violation of the territorial integrity and sovereignty of Ukraine
by the armed forces of the Russian Federation in early March 2014”,
and expressing their “gravest concern that members of the Upper
House of the Russian Parliament unanimously authorised such action
in advance”, the signatories expressed their conviction that there
had been a “serious violation of the basic principles of the Council
of Europe mentioned in Article 3 of, and the preamble to, the Statute”.
The second motion on the suspension of the voting rights of
the Russian delegation (Rule 9 of the Rules of Procedure of the
Assembly) (Doc. 13459
was signed by 53 members. In particular, the signatories expressed
their serious concern about “the persistent failure by the Russian
Federation to honour its obligations and commitments” as demonstrated
by the “actions of Russian military forces in the Crimean peninsula,
as well as explicit threats of military actions in the rest of Ukraine’s
territory”. Furthermore, they stressed that “the use of armed forces
on the territory of Ukraine was authorised by the Federation Council
of Russia on 1 March 2014”.
3. The Assembly considers that the actions of the Russian Federation
leading up to the annexation of Crimea, and in particular the military
occupation of the Ukrainian territory and the threat of the use
of military force, the recognition of the results of the illegal
so-called referendum and subsequent annexation of Crimea into the
Russian Federation constitute, beyond any doubt, a grave violation
of international law, including of the United Nations Charter and
the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE)
Helsinki Final Act. The launch of military action by Russia was
in violation of a memorandum signed between Russia, the United States
and the United Kingdom, and Ukraine, Belarus and Kazakhstan in 1994,
which undermines the trust in other international instruments, in
particular the agreements on disarmament and on non-proliferation of
These actions are also in clear contradiction with the Statute
of the Council of Europe, in particular its preamble, and the obligations
resulting from Article 3, as well as with the commitments undertaken
by the Russian Federation upon accession and contained in Assembly Opinion 193 (1996)
Russia’s request for membership of the Council of Europe.
5. The Assembly regrets that the Russian Federation has persistently
rejected the diplomatic efforts of the international community aimed
at the de-escalation of the situation, by turning down proposals
for international mediation and the establishment of an international
observer mission in Crimea, by refusing to enter into direct dialogue
with the authorities of Ukraine, and by choosing not to avail itself
of international mechanisms, including those available in the Council
of Europe, to peacefully resolve the conflict.
6. The Assembly believes that by violating the sovereignty and
territorial integrity of Ukraine, Russia has created a threat to
stability and peace in Europe. The annexation of Crimea and the
steps leading to it, have set a pattern which is now being followed
by other parts of Ukraine, as demonstrated by the developments in Donetsk,
Kharkiv and Lugansk since the first week of April.
7. The Assembly is particularly concerned by the position taken
by the members of both chambers of the Russian Parliament at different
stages of the process of annexation, including the unanimous vote
in the Council of the Federation authorising the use of military
force in Ukraine, the approval of constitutional amendments allowing
for the annexation of Crimea and the ratification of the illegal
treaty on unification.
8. The Assembly regrets that reports of alleged and unconfirmed
violations against the Russian-speaking minority and groundless
accusations about the extreme-right nature of the authorities in
Kyiv have been used for political purposes by many top officials
and members of parliament in the Russian Federation in their public statements.
9. The Assembly is deeply concerned by the state of media freedom
and freedom of expression in Russia, and in particular by the biased
coverage of the events in Ukraine, and even manipulations which
have largely contributed to the interethnic instability in the country,
as well as by suppression of the public debate and any criticism.
The crackdown on the independent media, including online media and
journalists, is most worrying.
The Assembly is deeply concerned by the continuous failure
of the Russian Federation to implement Resolution 1633 (2008)
on the consequences
of the war between Georgia and Russia, Resolution 1647 (2009)
on the implementation
of Resolution 1633 and Resolution
on the war between Georgia and Russia: one
year after, by the occupation of the Georgian provinces of Abkhazia
and South Ossetia by Russian troops and by the refusal of the Russian
Federation to allow European Union monitors and to reverse ethnic cleansing.
11. The present situation of minorities in Crimea, in particular
of Crimean Tatars and Ukrainians, raises the utmost concern. The
Assembly urges Russia, which is in illegal control of this territory,
to ensure that their rights are not violated.
12. The Assembly expresses its anxiety with regard to the intentions
of the Russian authorities in the light of the steady and noticeable
build-up of Russian military forces along its border with Ukraine.
Furthermore, it voices its concern about public statements made
by Russian officials with respect to the situation of Russian minorities
in a number of Council of Europe member States, which, in the present
context, raise understandable fears in the countries concerned.
13. The Assembly strongly condemns the violation of Ukrainian
sovereignty and territorial integrity by the Russian Federation,
and considers that such a flagrant violation by a Council of Europe
member State of its obligations and commitments requires a strong
signal of disapproval.
14. However, the Assembly believes that political dialogue should
remain the preferred way to find a compromise, and there should
be no return to the pattern of the Cold War. Suspension of the credentials
of the Russian delegation would make such a dialogue impossible,
while the Assembly constitutes a good platform for keeping the Russian
delegation accountable on the basis of Council of Europe’s values
and principles. The Parliamentary Assembly has the power and the
opportunity in this veritable crisis to confront face-to-face one of
its member States – the Russian Federation – with questions and
facts and to demand answers and accountability.
In consequence, in order to mark its condemnation and disapproval
of the Russian Federation's actions with regard to Ukraine, the
Assembly resolves to suspend the following rights of the delegation
of the Russian Federation until the end of the 2014 session:
15.1 voting rights;
15.2 right to be represented in the Bureau of the Assembly,
the Presidential Committee and the Standing Committee;
15.3 right to participate in election observation missions.
16. The Assembly reserves the right to annul the credentials of
the Russian delegation, if the Russian Federation does not de-escalate
the situation and reverse the annexation of Crimea.
17. The Assembly invites the Monitoring Committee to consider
setting up an investigative sub-committee tasked with examining
and following the developments since August 2013 relating to the