Logo Assembly Logo Hemicycle

Pushback action by member States

Motion for a resolution | Doc. 14645 | 11 October 2018

Ms Tineke STRIK, Netherlands, SOC ; Ms Thorhildur Sunna ÆVARSDÓTTIR, Iceland, SOC ; Ms Rósa Björk BRYNJÓLFSDÓTTIR, Iceland, UEL ; Ms Anastasia CHRISTODOULOPOULOU, Greece, UEL ; Ms Lise CHRISTOFFERSEN, Norway, SOC ; Mr Vernon COAKER, United Kingdom, SOC ; Ms Yolaine de COURSON, France, NR ; Ms Stella CREASY, United Kingdom, SOC ; Alexander [The Earl of] DUNDEE, United Kingdom, EC ; Mr Jonas GUNNARSSON, Sweden, SOC ; Mr Domagoj HAJDUKOVIĆ, Croatia, SOC ; Ms Eva-Lena JANSSON, Sweden, SOC ; Mr Tiny KOX, Netherlands, UEL ; Mr Zviad KVATCHANTIRADZE, Georgia, SOC ; Mr Killion MUNYAMA, Poland, EPP/CD ; Ms Carina OHLSSON, Sweden, SOC ; Mr Henk OVERBEEK, Netherlands, UEL ; Mr Georgios PSYCHOGIOS, Greece, UEL ; Ms Isabelle RAUCH, France, NR ; Lord Simon RUSSELL, United Kingdom, EC ; Ms Ulla SANDBÆK, Denmark, UEL ; Mr Stefan SCHENNACH, Austria, SOC ; Ms Angela SMITH, United Kingdom, SOC

Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights and Article 4 of the fourth Protocol thereto prohibit member States of the Council of Europe to return a migrant to another country without an individual assessment if this return is safe for the migrant in question. Despite the firm and clear judgements of the European Court of Human Rights in this regard (Hirsi, Sharifi, Khlaifia, N.D and N.T), there is still a practice of migrants being sent back automatically from the border or even from the main land. In some of these cases, member States claim that they were not responsible as the migrants had not yet reached their territory. The Court however has made clear that member States cannot limit their jurisdiction by creative constructions in order to circumvent their obligation to respect the human rights.

As this persistent practice of pushbacks leads to a clear risk of refoulement, it is an important threat to the necessary protection of refugees. It is therefore important that the Parliamentary Assembly reveals those practises and offers member States guidance on how they can protect their borders without violating the right to protection of refugees.

The resolution would map the standards and case law which constitute the legal framework of reference for the prohibition of push backs and collective expulsion. This mapping exercise would be followed by an overview of the practises in the member States, based on reports from independent sources and case-law from the European Court of Human Rights and national courts. This would form the basis for recommendations on the prevention of push backs and collective expulsions of migrants.