Logo Assembly Logo Hemicycle

PACE rapporteurs call for the Rwanda ‘return hub’ not to be pursued

PACE rapporteurs call for the suspension of the ‘return hub’ Rwanda agreement

Joint statement by Sandra Zampa (Italy, SOC), rapporteur for the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE) on “Council of Europe action to protect the human rights of migrants, asylum seekers and refugees” and Lord Michael German (United Kingdom, ALDE), PACE General Rapporteur on European migration and asylum policies:

“We deeply regret today’s announcement by five Council of Europe member states – Austria, Denmark, Germany, Greece and the Netherlands – to start negotiations to establish a ‘return hub’ in Rwanda.

This foresees the possibility for these five countries to deport irregular migrants and rejected asylum seekers who have exhausted all legal remedies to Rwanda, although they may never have set foot in this country.

A previous attempt to set up a similar scheme by the United Kingdom was notoriously blocked by the national Parliament and the courts due to serious human rights concerns in Rwanda, which persist today.

Return hubs are legally questionable, geopolitically risky and carry serious human rights risks. They are overly expensive and their alleged deterrent effect is unproven. They aim to appease anti-migrant sentiment as opposed to pursuing sound migration management.

This is why, in a June 2026 resolution, the Assembly – which brings together MPs from Council of Europe member states – made clear that they should avoid relying on them.

It appears this decision was made without consulting or informing the parliaments in the member states concerned and without human rights safeguards in place. The Council of Europe’s Human Rights Commissioner has recently called on states to make sure that before engaging in any return hub arrangement, they define its implications for people affected, comprehensively assess the human rights risks, establish effective measures to prevent violations and ensure transparency and democratic scrutiny. Yet so far none of these ‘guardrails’ seem to be in place.

We call on the governments of Austria, Germany, Greece, the Netherlands and Denmark not to pursue negotiations further, and to ensure that national parliaments are fully involved in any future projects of a similar nature.”